I received a budget ballot without the budget accompanying it.
There was correspondence about the sheriff and the deputy’s absence, but where was the explanation of the spending I was being asked to support? What increased? What decreased? What projects were included? How did the proposal compare with actual spending?
What am I voting for?
Surfside’s website advertises 2027 budget details and a summary behind the document sent in the budget vote. It also lists Zoom links for a budget workshop and budget committee meetings. Those resources exist and deserve acknowledgment. But both are attended by single digit attendance. But posting documents and holding a presentation do not ensure every voter receives an understandable explanation before returning a ballot.
Where is the clearly identified recorded presentation? Where are the slides, executive summary or explanations of major changes and a q and a with written answers to members’ questions?
Members who live elsewhere, work during meeting hours or cannot travel deserve the same opportunity to understand the budget as those who attend. Access to a workshop also does not establish that members can participate and vote remotely at the actual budget-ratification meeting.
A ballot should conclude an informed decision—not start a scavenger hunt.
Then comes the voting rule.
Under Washington’s budget-ratification framework, a budget generally takes effect unless owners holding a majority of all allocated association votes, or a larger percentage required by the declaration, reject it. A majority of the ballots returned is not enough.
For example, if an association has exactly 2,000 member voters. A rejection ordinarily requires 1,001 votes. If 800 vote no and 100 vote yes, the budget still passes.
A no vote remains a no vote. But when rejection requires participation far beyond ordinary turnout, members can reasonably question how much influence the process gives them.
Passing by default is not the same as winning member support.
The board did not create the state’s voting framework. It does control how clearly it explains the rules, distributes financial information and encourages participation. State law also contains budget-disclosure requirements; the rejection threshold does not eliminate those obligations.
This frustration grows when members also see their motions rejected or kept from a further membership vote. Each decision deserves a written explanation identifying what happened and the authority supporting it. Otherwise, members are left wondering where their input actually matters. For this HOA, it doesn’t.
The president, treasurer and board should provide a complete budget package with the ballot with comparisons to current spending, explanations of major changes, the full budget details not just summarize by department and a recorded presentation. Members should also receive clear instructions explaining how to participate and exactly how their votes count. An executive summary of the budget would certainly help voters. None of this matters.
Contracts—including deputy coverage—and expenditures outside the original plan deserve straightforward financial explanations. Members should not have to piece together the answers from separate meetings and correspondence.
So I decided to see what I’m voting on.downloaded the budget from the web site. It did not start outt well. Page 2 listed the 2027 expected revenue as 2411310 as did the distributed budget

On the next page it listed expected total revenue total as 2616610. Can you figure out the difference? If you wanted to vote not just on a summary of spending bit actual details, you couldn’t.

A simple error or something that needs explanation.
If I had presented a budget with a discrepancy like that to an Intel executive without explanation, the presentation would have stopped immediately, probably end up in a long discussion and I would have been sharply criticized for a lack of preparation, accuracy, and attention to detail. And most likely rejection of the budget. But I noticed some things:
2026 operating assessments came in $86,000 above what the per-lot rate explains. The 2026 rate of $516 × 2,873 lots works out to about $1,482,000, but $1,568,451 has been collected. Why?
High legal fees.
We spend a lot on legal fees
Legal fees
$50,000 budgeted for 2026;
$83,325 projected spent in 2026 ; $60,000 proposed for 2027
What explains the overrun and supports the new estimate? And what are the details of the legal expenses.
Utility income” is negative ($3,345). When did expense become an income?
Water treatment for lakes and canals.
$65,000 proposed;
$43,775 projected for 2026
What treatment, results and performance measures support the amount?
What is this heading under trash compactor headings

Another error.?
Deputy expenses
110000 budget for deputy expenses projected total 65557.
We paid 110000 for a deputy that got hurt. Those unpaid dollars goes where? But who negotiated a contract that did not take that into account. Being a deputy is a dangerous profession where they put their lives on the line all the time. But injury down time is always a possibility.
Taken together, legal fees, lake and canal treatments, and deputy services represent a significant expense. Using the figures provided, projected 2026 spending in these three categories totals $192,657—approximately 10.5% of the $1,841,932 approved 2026 operating budget shown in the presentation.
Are we getting our monies worth when we don:t have the deputy patrolling, algae blooms in the lake and a lawyer paid to write a letter to the planning commission to reduce the environmental protections around sea breeze lake and canals
At this point, I gave up trying to reconcile the numbers. I credit the treasurer for attempting to assemble a detailed budget, but a $200,000 discrepancy would have drawn serious scrutiny at Intel.
Financial information can be difficult to present accurately l, especially when it involves large sums and numerous figures. But the board members reviewed the detailed budget on the Surfside web site along with the president.
When I presented budgets for events and executive keynotes, my management, team members, and finance staff reviewed the figures closely. Even with multimillion-dollar budgets, every dollar had to be justified and accounted for line item by line item. In my experience, unspent funds could not simply be redirected to other purchases or returned to a general spending pool without proper approval. Reviews in front of any Intel manager would be highly scrutinized.
HOA members deserve the same financial discipline and clear explanations.
I decided to see what other HOAs provide their members before a budget vote.
I looked at another HOA with a membership of 3000. They provided the entire budget presentation in a YouTube video and a 66 page detailed budget presentation on their public web site.. Both detailed and informative. Its not a.summary of each department but a very detailed line item of every expenditure. It was great information and as a member provided full transparency of every dollar spent. They have an HOA newsletter that looks like a real newspaper with explanations of everything including articles by board members the general manager, editorial inputs from members, their own YouTube channel broadcasting their committee and board meetings, transcripts of meetings, articles on the bylaws etc. videos on how to vote. And they have electronic voting. What an amazing HOA?
Their dues are 175 a month
But they have a community center, fitness center, swimming pools, athletic facilities, clubs, community gardens, and rental spaces. Its waterfront amenities include a marina with wet and dry boat storage, a public boat launch, and kayak and canoe storage at six locations. RV storage is also available. They are HOA heaven.
Ironically, despite efforts to inform members on the budget benefits and provide a detailed budget, it. By the new law it passed even though 600 or 56% of votes cast opposed it.
Thanks to the new RCW 64.90.525 requires 1500+1 or 50% of voters to reject the budget. This means they were 900 no votes short. So despite a majority rejecting their budget, the HOA could continue with the new budget.
I do not believe I had an adequate explanation presented in the budget to make an informed decision. That should concern an association asking members to participate when they fail to provide budget information with an executive summary or details with a ballot to make a vote. For most members, receiving an envelope with no detailed budget included.
When information is difficult to assemble and the rejection threshold appears practically unreachable, a budget vote can feel like a procedural exercise with a predetermined outcome.
Before asking for my vote, explain what you intend to do with my money—and what my vote can actually change.
But in the state of Washington, the legislature has essentially silenced HOA voters by RCW 65.50.95. A lack of motions, the lack of information, and essentially a No vote that is rendered meaningless. The Surfside budget meeting is not in the cards since I live remotely and the meeting is not zoomed. But ultimately what’s the point. A 1000 votes are needed to get a budget rejected. How is that democracy?
